The uproar surrounding Lupita Nyong’o’s rumoured casting as Helen of Troy says far more about the people complaining than it does about the actress herself. Elon Musk and others have framed their objections as concerns about “historical accuracy”, yet Helen of Troy is a mythological figure, not a documented historical person. The backlash only intensified after Musk amplified posts arguing that Helen “must” be blonde and fair‑skinned, a stance that has been widely criticised as racially coded rather than artistically grounded. What we’re witnessing isn’t a debate about literature; it’s a debate about who is allowed to embody beauty, power and myth on screen.

Lupita Nyong’o’s career speaks for itself. An Oscar winner, she has delivered acclaimed performances in films such as 12 Years a Slave, Black Panther, Us and Queen of Katwe. She has navigated Hollywood with grace, professionalism and zero public scandal, consistently choosing roles that challenge stereotypes and broaden representation. While critics rage online, Nyong’o continues to work, to excel and to expand the boundaries of who gets to be seen as iconic. The idea that she is somehow unfit to portray a mythic figure says less about her talent and more about the discomfort some people feel when Black women occupy spaces traditionally reserved for whiteness.

Black Panther became one of the most successful films in cinema history, earning well over a billion dollars worldwide and massively outperforming its budget: Image Credit: Observer.Com

And let’s be honest: acting is, by definition, the art of becoming someone you are not. Cinema has always played fast and loose with identity. There were Black presidents in films long before Barack Obama entered the White House. Peter Andre, a white man, once portrayed a Black Jamaican character in Jafaican without sparking a global meltdown.

Jafaican struggled at the box office, with its poor performance reflecting wider issues in the film rather than any single actor or role. 

Yet when a Black actress is cast in a role historically imagined as white, suddenly the integrity of Western civilisation is at stake. The double standard is glaring, and the outrage feels less like concern for storytelling and more like anxiety over shifting cultural power.  The reaction to Nyong’o’s casting exposes how racism adapts to modern discourse: it cloaks itself in arguments about “accuracy”, “tradition” and “authenticity”, while policing who is allowed to embody beauty, desirability and myth.

Lupita Nyong’o, born in Mexico City and raised in Kenya, has built a remarkable career with more than 30 screen roles and an impressive collection of 118 awards and 124 nominations: Image Credit People.Com

At the end of the day, this is a film. It is a performance. It is an actor doing her job. The real story isn’t whether Lupita Nyong’o can play Helen of Troy — she can, brilliantly. The real story is why some people still cannot accept that the face that launches a thousand ships might also be Black.

  Follow JamRadio: